Recently a leaked memo has been the subject of much conversation. This memo:

Unfortunately it doesn't look too good here, but follow
this link to see it better if you would like. The front page is pretty harmless, actually. It's the subsequent content that shows how disgusting the anti-health care reform people are. It's best supplemented with a number of videos on youtube, but Rachel Maddow has a great summation of it all here:
was Thomas Sowell purposely left off of your list of pundits because he's black?
ReplyDelete"So, it comes down to fear and the manipulators who spread the fear. I just hope that the people can be intelligent enough to know that they can make decisions for themselves. All they have to do is shut out the noise."
ReplyDeleteExcellent point.
Who's to say the guy in your opening paragraph was influenced by 'the noise' though? Because if they weren't listening to 'the noise' they'd side with you???
It's not like Beck, Limbaugh and Hannity just conjure up bullshit to shovel at the Obama administration. Things happen, they reply.
Just because the right is overt about "the fear" doesn't mean that they're wrong on every level. For example what's wrong with your health care? Personally speaking that is.
The left lead you to believe that you have something to fear about your health care, quality, quantity or otherwise, just as much as the right says you should fear the universal health care that the left is trying to push upon it's followers...
To say it's one party limited would be obtuse if not absurd.
My problem with Health care reform being on the right?
The President takes 6 weeks to decide what Dog he wants to get for his daughters but wants to pass legislation on a health care bill for the whole country in less time. WTF... That and I think we're not focusing on the correct things. Health care in our country is as good as ever (if you can get it, that's another story), the health care industry doesn't need reform, the insurance industry does... coupled with the cost of receiving medical care. It's not the CARE that needs reform.
More on this later if you so choose...
First of all, who is Thomas Sowell? I'll have to look him up later if I get a chance in between Balance Sheets and P&L Reports.
ReplyDeleteSecond of all, I can only assume that your casual dismissal of organized mobs shouting down elected representatives and bullying attendees in to silence means you condone this behavior. It seems like you are shifting the focus away from the main topic when my concern lies with disgusting behavior that is taking place at what is supposed to be a civilized forum. As I said, regardless of how you feel about the reform itself, it would seem that this is decidedly undemocratic. Again, if the health care reform is so bad, why not let the people find out for themselves, rather than not allowing the information to be presented.
As for fear, I am going to have to completely disagree with you. Obama and those pushing for reform are not trying to scare the insured into thinking that horrible things are going to happen to them if it does not get approved. Their concern is for those who do not have, choose not to have, or can not afford health insurance. Indeed, it seems that whenever Obama has publicly discussed this legislation he spends most of his time trying to assuage fears that are stirred up by Republican criticism.